• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Corporate News
  • Generation
  • Oil & Gas
  • Regulation
  • Renewable
    • Climate
    • Solar
    • Wind
  • Storage
  • Tech
  • T & D
Energy News Desk Logo

Energy News Desk

Energy News and Data

14 states press EPA to rescind coronavirus-driven enforcement policy as NGOs file lawsuit

April 17, 2020 by Utility Dive

Dive Brief:

  • 14 state attorneys general, led by New York’s Letitia James, wrote Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Andrew Wheeler on Wednesday demanding the agency rescind its recent policy providing more compliance flexibility to power plants and other regulated entities during the coronavirus pandemic. 
  • The attorneys general say the policy significantly curtails “enforcement of our nation’s bedrock environmental and public health laws,” but EPA on April 2 pushed back on criticism that it is shirking its responsibilities. And industry says it expects to need the flexibility only in extreme cases.
  • Meanwhile, the Natural Resources Defense Council and 14 other groups sued the agency in federal district court on Thursday, alleging the agency’s failure to respond to their administrative petition requesting changes to the policy is “unreasonable and unlawful.”

Dive Insight:

These are extraordinary times, and the attorneys general recognize that. But there are limits to what EPA should do in response, they note.

“Although it is appropriate for EPA to consider whether safeguards that businesses are taking against the coronavirus impact their ability to comply with those laws, the agency cannot — in the midst of a public health crisis — lose sight of its mission to protect public health and the environment,” they write.

“[W]e are particularly concerned about the agency’s lack of consideration of the policy’s potential impact on public health, especially the health of low income and minority communities who are greater risk of suffering adverse outcomes from COVID-19,” the letter continues.

The attorneys general vowed to continue enforcing state environmental laws “in a reasonable manner” and said they would hold regulated entities accountable under federal laws if EPA will not.

In addition to New York, which is facing the worst of the pandemic in the U.S., attorneys general from Illinois, Iowa, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, Washington and Wisconsin also signed the letter.

EPA first announced the revised enforcement policy March 26, drawing immediate fire from environmental groups and others. Former EPA Administrator Gina McCarthy, who now heads the Natural Resources Defense Council, called it “an open license to pollute” and “an abdication of the EPA’s responsibility.”

EPA enforcement chief Susan Bodine on April 2 responded to critical letters from House and Senate Democrats, calling their allegations “irresponsible.”

“The idea that EPA is giving industry a license to pollute mischaracterizes the agency’s response … EPA expects regulated facilities to comply with regulatory requirements, where reasonably practicable, and to return to compliance as quickly as possible, once the COVID-19 threat subsides,” she wrote.

Power plant operators say they only expect to need compliance flexibility in extreme scenarios. In addition, under the new policy, operators would have to prove that any environmental violations were directly due to disruptions stemming from the novel coronavirus.

But NGOs are not satisfied with such assurances and have gone a step further than the attorneys general, filing a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

In their April 1 petition, the groups asked EPA to publish a rule within seven days and make it effective immediately “requiring any entity that stops monitoring and reporting for environmental pollution in response to the COVID-19 pandemic to provide written notice and justification to EPA, which EPA would then make available to the public,” the lawsuit states. 

The groups says EPA’s current policy allows companies to document any non-compliance “internally” and inform the agency about it later, if asked.

“The COVID-19 pandemic has caused widespread disruption and harm. But EPA’s unprecedented non-enforcement policy risks suppressing critical data and information and creates a clear opportunity for abuse,” the complaint continues.

The groups are asking the court to order EPA to respond to their April 1 petition as soon as possible and no later than five days after a judgment is entered.

Original source: Utility Dive

Filed Under: Climate, Regulation, Renewable

Primary Sidebar

Join The Daily Charge

This week's top 5 stories in your inbox. No spam ever.

Trending

  • Orsted, PGE Partner on Baltic Sea Offshore Wind Projects
  • Offshore Wind Market for Jack-Up Interventions on the Rise
  • Capital Dynamics Sells Majority Stake of Beacon Solar Portfolio
  • Renewable Properties Begins Construction on Lake Herman Solar Project
  • Agilitas Energy, CarVal Investors Reach Close on Solar Portfolio
  • Point Load Power Launches the PV Booster Gen 2
  • Pelosi steps back on infrastructure push as renewable industry vies for aid
  • New Golden Spiral Wind Turbine Proves Concept in Wind Test
  • eia.gov logo Motor gasoline accounted for almost half of U.S. petroleum consumption in 2019
  • ALLETE Clean Energy Agrees to Sell 100 MW from Caddo Wind Site

Footer

Trending

  • Orsted, PGE Partner on Baltic Sea Offshore Wind Projects
  • Offshore Wind Market for Jack-Up Interventions on the Rise
  • Capital Dynamics Sells Majority Stake of Beacon Solar Portfolio
  • Renewable Properties Begins Construction on Lake Herman Solar Project
  • Agilitas Energy, CarVal Investors Reach Close on Solar Portfolio

Recent

  • Quick Tips To A Sustainable Future
  • Stem Provides Smart Energy Storage Solutions to Today’s Power
  • EIA's AEO2021 shows U.S. energy-related CO2 emissions rising after the mid-2030s
  • Homeowners associations still a barrier for some would-be solar customers
  • Commentary: With open standards, U.S. can build EV charging infrastructure faster

Search

Contact Us

Write For Us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2022 · EnergyNewsDesk.com